The only one she will take is the one I got from the hospital, the soothie. I know thumb sucking can be bad, but there are so many opinions on it out there. The thing about pacifiers is that they fall out and she freaks as soon as it does, lol. I am at a loss, I know if she could suck her thumb she would probably be sleeping a lot longer at night. Oh well, I will just pray this phase is soon over, thanks for the advice.